The $35 Scotch That Reminded Me About Pricing

Issue #607Sent Monday, November 16, 2026 12 min read
In this issue
WP Edge Newsletter Issue #607 featured image

Happy to be back from our trip to Hawaii. Great trip, but the sure sign it did its job is that you’re happy to be home. Mission accomplished. 🤪

For a bit there, I was concerned that all of that airline chaos from the FAA shutdown would make it difficult to get back, but we lucked out. No issues at all. In fact, we even landed a bit early. 😎

So, jumping into the week here. Some client stuff to catch up on, of course. Time to spin up the content wheels again. Thanksgiving’s coming up… and all the Black Friday noise with it. No Black Friday deals from me, though. And, if you find yourself falling for a shiny object in the WordPress world during this Black Friday run, feel free to shoot me an email to ask my thoughts. I’ll give you the straight scoop.

This week: what a $35 scotch reminded me about pricing, and the short version of a podcast I was just on about AI and WordPress.

OK, let’s roll…


A Cruise Ship Reminder About Pricing

I’ve lost count of how many cruises I’ve done at this point. Probably 10 or 15. So nothing about this one surprised me… but it did remind me of something I’ve known about pricing for a long time.

It started before we even boarded, right after airport security. You’re through TSA, you’ve got time to kill, and you’re hungry. So you walk up to one of those little grab-and-go spots and pay about double what that sandwich would cost anywhere else.

You know it’s a ripoff. Everybody standing in that line knows it’s a ripoff.

And everybody pays it anyway.

Then we got on the ship. Same thing, different setting. Want a cocktail or a beer? Sure. It’s going to cost you well over what you’d pay at a decent bar back home. And people order them all day long. Myself included. One night I dropped about $35 on a double scotch on the rocks. 😅

It’s the classic captive audience. And sure, part of it is that there’s nowhere else to go. But watching it play out again, I was reminded of what’s really going on…

Nobody was really making a decision about price. They were in a certain mode, in a certain place, and the price was just… there.

Why we pay it anyway

At the airport, it’s speed and convenience. You’re hungry now. Your flight boards in 40 minutes. The food is right there. You’re not going to leave the terminal to save a few bucks, and the airport knows it.

On the ship, it’s the experience. I’m on vacation in Hawaii. I already decided this whole trip was worth it… and compared to the cost of the cruise, one drink is a rounding error. And paying is painless. I don’t pull out a wallet. I just hand over my room key card and they charge it to the cabin. I don’t really feel it until the bill shows up at the end of the week.

And that’s the lesson I keep coming back to. When somebody’s deciding whether to buy your main offer, price is very rarely the real reason they say yes or no.

“Too expensive” usually means something else

I get it. When sales are slow, the first instinct is to lower the price. Run a discount.

But try this test. If you cut your price by 30% tomorrow, would the people who didn’t buy suddenly buy?

Usually not. Because price wasn’t what stopped them.

When somebody says “it’s too expensive,” what they usually mean is “I’m not convinced yet.” They’re not sure it’ll work for them. Or they don’t trust you enough yet. Or the problem isn’t painful enough right now to do something about.

I saw this firsthand a few weeks ago when I took a hard look at Concierge pricing. It turned out I’d been underpriced for a long time. And the people buying weren’t the ones looking for the cheapest option anyway.

What people actually pay for

A while back, I wrote about the 5 things people will pay the most money for. The airport and the cruise ship are two of them, live and in person.

1. Speed and convenience. That’s the airport. People want the result now, without a hassle. If your offer gets them there faster, or tells them exactly what to do in what order so they don’t have to figure it out, that’s worth real money.

2. Done for you. Nobody on that ship was making their own drinks. You wouldn’t even be able to. People pay a premium to have the work handled. It’s the whole idea behind Concierge.

3. An experience. That’s the cruise. People don’t just pay for the thing. They pay for how it feels and for the story they get to tell afterward.

4. Being ahead of the pack. People pay to get in early and know something useful before everybody else does. Right now that’s a lot of the AI stuff… as long as it’s actually useful, not “secret strategy” fluff.

5. Access. The biggie. We had the suite card (because my father had a suite), which got us into some of the specialty restaurants. People pay for that kind of access. Online, it’s real time with a real person who knows their stuff… the one thing AI can’t copy.

Notice that “a lower price” isn’t on the list. But the pricing psychology is all over how that cruise line does things.

Your website isn’t a captive audience

Here’s where the analogy breaks down. Your visitors aren’t trapped… your competition is one browser tab away. And you wouldn’t want to trap them anyway. People pay airport prices, but they resent it.

So the goal is to create the conditions where price stops being the main thing on their mind. Here’s how that looks on a website.

Catch them when the problem is real. The airport works because you’re hungry right now. You can’t make somebody’s problem urgent. But you can show up when it is. Content that answers the question they’re asking today. Emails that land when they’re thinking about it.

Sell the outcome before the price shows up. By the time somebody’s on that cruise ship, they’ve already bought into the vacation. Same with your offer. If your content and emails have already sold them on the result, the price on the sales page is just a detail.

Make it easy to say yes. A confusing sales page, a vague offer, or a checkout that feels like filling out a tax return… that loses more sales than price ever will.

Be the obvious choice. People comparison shop when every option looks the same. Be specific about who you help and what they get. Show proof. Give them reasons to trust you. Then they stop opening five other tabs.

Price usually comes last. Funny enough… sometimes the answer is to raise it. 😉


WordPress News & Updates

Hostinger had a server broken into, through somebody else’s website. An attacker got in through an outdated CMS on one customer’s site, then used an unknown flaw in the LiteSpeed web server to break out of that account and into others on the same server. About 400 accounts had code run or credentials read, including database passwords. Hostinger moved everyone, restored from backups and patched its whole fleet. This is the risk of shared hosting in a nutshell… your site’s security depends partly on your neighbors. Hostinger’s incident report.

PHP2Shell turned out to be mostly noise for WordPress. Remember the PHP security panic a few weeks ago? Three weeks later, nobody has confirmed a single WordPress site hacked through it. Cloudflare had firewall rules in place almost 11 hours before PHP even released the patches. The bigger lesson was how unevenly hosts kept their customers informed. If yours went silent, that tells you something. The Repository’s write-up.

WooCommerce is using AI to find its own security holes… and dropping old PHP. Every change to WooCommerce’s code now gets an automated AI security scan, and it’s finding real problems that get fixed in regular updates. Also worth knowing: WooCommerce 11.6, due in February, will require PHP 8.1 or newer. If your store is on older hosting, now’s a good time to check your PHP version. What Woo has been doing.

Spammers are signing up with other people’s email addresses. After reports of spam registrations using real people’s emails, Matt Mullenweg is calling for WordPress to be stricter about what it accepts when someone registers. If your site lets people create accounts (a membership, a course, a store), keep an eye on your new users list. His post.

Not everybody loves the /random/ button. Last week I mentioned WordPress 7.2’s new /random/ URL that sends visitors to a random post. Plenty of developers pushed back on it being on by default. Yoast’s founder worried visitors could randomly land on invoices, offers or client-specific pages. There’s already a No Random Posts plugin to switch it off. If your site has private-ish content sitting in regular posts, it’s worth a look before December 8. The pushback.

WordPress now has a “flagship” theme called Mētis. It was originally going to be the next default theme, until Matt Mullenweg went with the simpler Ipsum instead. Now Mētis lives on as a showcase of what the block editor can do: six starter sites (business, magazine, portfolio and more), 50 patterns and six style variations. It doesn’t ship with WordPress 7.2, so you’d install it separately. The announcement.

AI site builders are taking off… and WordPress isn’t part of it. GoDaddy’s AI builder, Airo, just passed $100 million a year in bookings, doubling in one quarter. Plumbers and car dealers are building their own sites. And Automattic (the company behind WordPress.com) launched Spacefast, a place to host whatever your chatbot builds… which doesn’t run WordPress at all. Meanwhile, WordPress’s market share is down to about 39%. More on why I’m not worried in this week’s second article. GoDaddy’s earnings call.

“It looks done” isn’t the same as done. WebDevStudios built a fun little site that puts a vibe-coded website and a WordPress site through the same launch day. Bots show up. Spam hits the contact form. Somebody uploads a giant image. Somebody needs to fix a typo. It’s a great picture of all the stuff WordPress quietly handles that an AI-built prototype doesn’t. Take the tour.

6% of WooCommerce stores couldn’t take a guest order. NorthDuty tested 201 live stores ahead of Black Friday. Twelve of them couldn’t complete a guest checkout, mostly because no payment method showed up. Your price doesn’t matter much if people can’t actually pay you. Go buy something from your own store this week. The study.

FluentCart rebuilt its order bumps. Order bumps are those “add this too?” offers right before you pay, and they used to be stuck under the order notes. Now you can show them in the cart, choose where they sit at checkout, and pick from six designs. A related add-on, offered at the moment somebody’s already buying, is about as easy a yes as it gets. (Kinda like that drink by the pool.) The release notes.

FluentCommunity can now run events. Version 2.14 lets you post a live Q&A, workshop or meetup inside a community space, with RSVPs, a countdown and an “Add to Google Calendar” link. FluentCRM tags can now also give people course or space access when they register. If you run a membership, that’s one less outside tool. What’s new.

Reprint makes a copy of your site to play with. It’s a free plugin that clones your live WordPress site to your computer, another server, or WordPress Playground right in your browser. Handy for testing a change, or letting AI loose on a copy instead of the real thing. The plugin.

WP Engine is putting a leash on bots. It now keeps at least 20% of a site’s server capacity reserved for real humans, so AI crawlers and other bots can’t crowd them out. That tells you how much bot traffic sites are dealing with these days. If your site has felt sluggish lately, bots might be part of the reason. WP Engine’s post.


AI on WordPress Is Only as Good as Its Guide

I was a guest on the MemberFix Radio podcast recently, and we spent most of the conversation on one topic: using AI on a WordPress site without wrecking it.

I’ll give you the short version here. If you want the whole conversation, you can catch the episode here.

The most confident idiot in the world

That’s how I described AI on the show. It’ll do almost anything you ask… and it’ll be totally sure of itself while it does it. Even when it’s wrong.

I’ve seen both ends of this with clients. One used AI to redesign parts of his site, and it went great. The AI used proper Gutenberg blocks, and he did the work on a staging copy first. Another tried Claude Code on their own and ended up with a custom HTML block full of gibberish… and a site they could no longer edit.

Same tools. Very different results. The difference was the person guiding it.

I’m not telling anybody to stay away from AI. I use it every single day. I just think you need to use it in an educated way.

Three habits that keep it on the rails

1. Give it what it can’t know. AI doesn’t know your business, your customers, or what actually happened last week. So I bring that part. With this newsletter, for example, I talk through my ideas and real examples, AI helps shape a draft, and I do the final edit. It’s saved me maybe 20-30% of my time. Not 90%. An issue still takes me a couple of hours.

2. Keep a record outside the AI. If the only record of how something on your site works lives inside an old chat session, you’re in trouble. Nearly everything AI builds for my site gets documented in my Obsidian vault. That way it’s not locked inside one tool, and the next person (or the next AI) can pick it up.

3. Get a second opinion on code. When I have AI build a custom plugin, I have a separate AI agent review the code for security holes. It’s like having a second set of eyes… and it catches things.

Why WordPress gives AI a head start

We also talked about why I’m keeping WordPress underneath everything, even after moving the public side of Blog Marketing Academy to Astro.

WordPress is open source and documented to death. AI already knows it inside and out. And it gives you a real login and editor, which matters the minute a second person needs to edit anything. I see no sense in having AI rebuild tools like FluentCRM or WP Fusion from scratch. They already work.

And for those of us who’ve been doing WordPress a long time, AI changes what’s practical. I recently replaced an off-the-shelf plugin for a client with a custom one that does exactly what they need. I knew how it should work… I just never would’ve sat down and coded it myself before.

That’s really the point. AI makes your knowledge more valuable, not less. It just needs somebody steering.

If you want the full conversation, give the episode a listen.

David Risley

Enjoyed this one?

Get the next issue in your inbox Monday morning. Free, one email a week.

Curious what I do?


Be On A First-Name Basis With Your “Web Guy”

Learn More About Concierge
  • WP Speed Fix. Get the performance scores and core web vitals for your website fixed. Let me deal with the nerdy stuff. And let’s make your site purr like a kitten.
  • Technical Service: Going cross-eyed with WordPress plugins, theme changes, membership site setup, automations? Having difficulty making it all work? I can handle it. Ala carte work, as needed. No contracts.
  • Book A Call Anytime!. You can book either a strategy call (to talk strategy and planning) or an implementation session (where we'll work on your site together).
  • ONEPass – All Access Pass To Every Course In The Library. For one small one-time purchase, you can unlock every course in the Blog Marketing Academy library. For life.
  • Get Some Anytime Credits. Use credits on your account to book development work or calls. Credits don't expire, so services are flexible and "pay as you go".

The WP Edge is the official weekly newsletter of the Blog Marketing Academy.
Sent every Monday.